Our Preparation Speaks For Itself.

Commercial Trucking $4.2 Million

Recovered for a client who sustained a spinal injury when a commercial carrier's driver exceeded federal hours-of-service limits. Electronic logging data preserved within days of the collision established the violation.

Case results media

Medical Negligence $3.1 Million

Settlement for a family following a delayed diagnosis that resulted in permanent neurological injury. Chart review identified a documentation gap around a critical change in the patient's condition.

Case results media

Premises Liability $2.4 Million

Recovered on behalf of a client assaulted in a commercial parking structure where prior incidents had been documented and no additional security measures were implemented.

Case results media

Wrongful Death $2.8 Million

Resolved for the surviving family of a client killed in a collision involving a commercial vehicle with documented maintenance deficiencies preceding the crash.

Case results media

Workplace Injury $1.9 Million

Third-party recovery against an equipment manufacturer following an injury that workers' compensation alone would have compensated at a small fraction of the client's actual lifetime losses.

Case results media

Motor Vehicle Collision $1.4 Million

Settled following suit where the insurer's pre-litigation offer reflected a small fraction of the client's documented future care costs and diminished earning capacity.

Case results media

Client Testimonials What Our Clients Say

“They told me the truth from the start”

Two other firms gave me a number in the first meeting. Marchetti & Vance gave me a range and explained what would move it.

Two other firms quoted me a figure in the first meeting, which I later learned means very little. Marchetti & Vance gave me a range instead and walked through what would push my case toward the top or bottom of it. Eighteen months later the settlement landed near the upper end. I never felt like I was being sold anything.

“The partner actually handled my case”

I met the attorney at the first meeting and he was still the one calling me two years later.

My experience with a previous firm was meeting a lawyer once and then dealing with a case manager for a year. Here I met Daniel at the first meeting and he was still the one calling me two years later. When we finally went to mediation, he knew details about my treatment that I had forgotten telling anyone.

“They handled everything while I recovered”

The medical bills and provider calls stopped landing on me, which mattered more than I expected.

After my surgery I could barely manage my own appointments, let alone a stack of bills from providers I did not remember seeing. Their staff took all of it over within about a week. It sounds like a small thing next to the legal work but at the time it was the difference between coping and not.

“They turned down the first offer without hesitating”

The insurer's offer looked large to me. Elena explained exactly why it was not.

The first offer looked like an enormous amount of money to someone who had been out of work for eight months. Elena sat down and walked me through the projected cost of my future care, and the number stopped looking large. We rejected it, filed suit, and eventually resolved for substantially more.

“She understood my medical records better than my doctors explained them”

Priya's nursing background meant I finally understood what had actually happened to my mother.

Priya read through my mother's chart and explained the sequence of what happened in language we could follow, which nobody at the hospital had managed to do. That clarity was worth a great deal to our family independent of the legal outcome. She also identified the issue that the case ultimately turned on.

“They told me I did not need a lawyer”

I came in expecting to be signed up. They advised me to handle it myself and explained how.

I came in with what I thought was a serious claim and expected to be signed up on the spot. Instead they explained that my case was straightforward enough that a lawyer's fee would likely cost me more than the representation added, and told me how to handle it directly with the insurer. That is not what I expected and it is why I have recommended them since.

“Prepared in a way the other side clearly was not”

At mediation, our exhibits were finished and theirs were not. It changed the tone immediately.

I did not understand what preparation meant in a legal context until mediation. Our materials were complete, organized, and easy to follow. The other side's attorney seemed to be seeing some of it for the first time. The tone of the discussion shifted within the first hour and the offer moved substantially.

“Calls returned the same day, every time”

Over two years I never once had to chase them for an answer.

My case took just over two years and I never once had to call twice about the same question. If Daniel was in trial, someone told me so and gave me a realistic time he would get back to me, and he always did. Compared to what friends have described of other firms, that consistency was remarkable.

“They found coverage nobody else had looked for”

The at-fault driver had almost no insurance. They found another policy that changed everything.

The driver who hit me carried minimal coverage and I had been told my case was worth very little as a result. Elena looked at whether he had been working at the time and found a commercial policy that applied. That single piece of work changed the value of my claim by an order of magnitude.

“They guided us through the process after my father died”

The paperwork and court filings were handled entirely so our family could grieve.

After my father was killed we had no capacity to deal with opening an estate or any of the filings that a wrongful death claim apparently requires. They handled the entire process and only involved us when a decision genuinely needed to be ours. We were treated as a family going through something terrible rather than as a case file.

The attorneys at Marchetti & Vance
Attorney helping a client
Miami skyscrapers

Who We Are Prepared. Selective. Unhurried.

Marchetti & Vance is a Tampa trial firm representing people who have been seriously hurt. We take a deliberately small number of cases so that each one receives the preparation that produces leverage, and we tell clients honestly at the outset what we believe their claim is worth and what it will take to get there.

Insurance carriers keep records on opposing counsel. They know which firms file suit and which ones send demand letters and wait. They know which lawyers have picked a jury in the last five years. That institutional memory is invisible to clients but it sets the value of every claim before a word is negotiated, and building the right reputation was the founding purpose of this firm.

In practice that means we prepare the case we hope never to try. Depositions are taken as though a jury will read them. Experts are retained early rather than in response to a motion. Medical records are organized into a coherent narrative from the first month. When the carrier evaluates the file, the preparation is what it sees, and the offer reflects it.

A case is worth what the other side believes you are prepared to do about it. Everything else in this profession is commentary.

Tampa Bay's Trial Bench

Every case at Marchetti & Vance is assigned to a partner who stays with it through resolution. You will not be handed off to a case manager after the first meeting, and the attorney who signs your file is the one who will stand up in court if it comes to that.

Elena Marchetti, Esq.
Founding Partner

Elena Marchetti, Esq.

Elena spent the first seven years of her career defending commercial trucking companies and their insurers, work that taught her exactly how those claims are valued internally long before any demand is made. She moved to the plaintiff's side in 2011 and now leads the firm's trucking and catastrophic injury practice. Opposing counsel know her for exhaustive deposition preparation and for declining offers that most firms would have recommended their clients accept.

Case Types Areas of Practice

Our practice centers on catastrophic injury, wrongful death, and the categories of negligence that produce them. Below are the case types we handle most often, each staffed by a partner who has tried this kind of case before a jury rather than only settled them.

Car Accidents

Collision claims involving serious injury, disputed liability, or an insurer that has undervalued what happened to you. We handle the investigation, the medical documentation, and the negotiation.

Car Accidents

Truck Accidents

Commercial vehicle collisions involve federal regulation, corporate defendants, and rapid evidence preservation. Our founding partner spent seven years defending these carriers.

Truck Accidents

Medical Negligence

Claims arising from surgical error, missed diagnosis, medication mistakes, and inadequate monitoring. Led by a partner who practiced critical care nursing for nine years.

Medical Negligence

Wrongful Death

Representation for families following a death caused by negligence, handling the procedural requirements so the family is not managing litigation during grief.

Wrongful Death

Premises Liability

Injuries caused by dangerous property conditions or inadequate security, including falls, structural failures, and assaults that a property owner should have prevented.

Premises Liability

Workplace Injuries

Serious on-the-job injuries where a third party outside your employer bears responsibility, allowing recovery beyond the limits of workers' compensation.

Workplace Injuries

We would rather turn away a case we cannot properly staff than take a fee for work we know will be rushed.

— Elena Marchetti

The Rosen Brothers

Founding Partners Marchetti & Vance

Elena Marchetti and Daniel Vance met as opposing counsel and spent four years on opposite sides of trucking and premises cases before concluding they would rather build something together than keep taking turns beating each other.

The firm they founded reflects that history. Elena spent her early career defending commercial carriers and knows precisely how those files are evaluated internally, which is an unusual advantage when the same carriers are on the other side. Daniel came up through the public defender's office and has tried more cases to verdict than most civil attorneys will see in a career. Between them the firm covers both halves of the work: knowing what the other side will do, and being genuinely ready when they do it.

Our Trial Attorneys

THE MARCHETTI & VANCE DIFFERENCE Why Clients Choose This Firm

Clients generally come to us after speaking with two or three other firms. The distinction they report noticing is that we were willing to tell them something they did not want to hear about their case, and were specific about what we would do rather than how hard we would fight.

Direct Attorney Access

Every file is assigned to a partner who remains on it from intake through resolution. There is no handoff to a case manager after signing, and the attorney you meet is the one who will try the case.

We keep the caseload small enough to make that promise real. It is the primary constraint on how much work this firm accepts, and we treat it as non-negotiable.

Clients receive a candid valuation early, including the weaknesses. Knowing the range at the outset is what allows someone to make a sound decision when an offer arrives eighteen months later.

Read More About Us
Miami office photo

In The News

Tampa firm secures recovery in commercial trucking case involving hours-of-service violations

Attorneys for the plaintiff preserved electronic logging data within days of the collision, establishing that the carrier's driver had substantially exceeded federal limits before the crash.

Read Article (opens in a new tab)
Photo Credit: Local Press news media

Attorneys discuss what Florida's comparative fault changes mean for injured claimants

Partners from the firm outline how recent amendments to Florida's comparative negligence framework affect the way insurers evaluate and negotiate claims where fault is contested.

Read Article (opens in a new tab)
Photo Credit: Local Press news media

Nurse-turned-attorney on why medical negligence claims are so often misjudged

A firm partner with nine years of critical care nursing experience explains how clinical documentation is read differently by treating providers, outside experts, and juries.

Read Article (opens in a new tab)
Photo Credit: Local Press news media

We're Ready To Fight for You

Contact us media

The offer you receive is a measurement of what the other side thinks you will actually do.

— Daniel Vance

In the Community Giving Back

The firm provides pro bono representation to Tampa Bay families who fall outside the economics of a contingency practice, typically cases involving real harm but limited insurance coverage. We also support local legal aid organizations and participate in clinics that help injured workers understand their rights before they have committed to any representation. This work does not generate revenue and we do not publicize the individual matters, but it is a meaningful share of what the firm does each year.

Giving back
Mothers Against Drunk Drivers logo
Boys & Girls Club of Miami-Dade logo
The Fishing Experience logo
City Year logo

Free & Confidential Free & Confidential Case Evaluation

If you or a loved one has been the victim of negligence or misconduct, please do not hesitate to contact some of the most effective attorneys Miami has available at Marchetti & Vance today to receive guidance about your legal options with a free and confidential case evaluation.

Free Case Evaluation media

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire Marchetti & Vance?

Nothing upfront. We work exclusively on a contingency fee basis, which means our fee is a percentage of what we recover and we are paid only if we recover something. Case costs such as expert fees, court filing fees, and deposition transcripts are advanced by the firm as the matter proceeds rather than billed to you along the way. The specific percentage is set out in a written agreement before we begin, and we will walk you through it in plain terms.

How long do I have to file a claim in Florida?

Florida's statute of limitations for most negligence claims is two years from the date of the injury, though shorter deadlines apply in certain circumstances, particularly claims against government entities, which can require formal notice within months. Some claims involving medical negligence have their own timing rules. Because a missed deadline generally ends a claim permanently regardless of its merit, the safest course is to have the specific dates reviewed early rather than assuming a general rule applies to your situation.

What is my case actually worth?

Honest answer: nobody can tell you precisely at the first meeting, and you should be cautious of any lawyer who does. Value depends on the severity and permanence of the injury, the available insurance coverage, the clarity of liability, and the jurisdiction. What we can do early is give you a realistic range and explain what would move your case toward the upper or lower end of it. We update that assessment as the medical picture becomes clearer.

Will my case go to trial?

Most cases resolve before trial, and yours probably will. But we prepare every file as though it will be tried, because that preparation is precisely what produces a fair settlement offer. Insurance carriers evaluate whether opposing counsel is genuinely willing and able to try the case, and they adjust their numbers accordingly. Firms that never try cases are known and are discounted.

What should I do immediately after an accident?

Get medical attention first, even if you feel able to wait, because gaps in treatment are used later to argue the injury was not serious. Report the incident to the appropriate authorities and get a report number. Photograph the scene, the vehicles or hazard, and any visible injuries. Avoid giving a recorded statement to the other side's insurer before speaking with a lawyer, and do not accept a quick payment in exchange for signing a release.

The insurance company already offered me money. Should I take it?

Not before someone reviews it. Early offers frequently arrive before the full extent of an injury is known, and accepting one generally requires signing a release that permanently ends your claim, including for treatment you have not yet had. If surgery becomes necessary six months later, that cost is yours. Having the offer evaluated costs nothing and takes very little time.

How long will my case take to resolve?

It varies considerably. Straightforward claims with clear liability and completed treatment can resolve in several months. Cases involving serious injuries usually take longer, in part because we generally wait until your medical condition has stabilized before valuing the claim, since settling earlier risks undervaluing future care. Litigated matters run longer still. We will give you a realistic timeline for your specific case and update it as things develop.

What compensation can I recover?

Depending on the facts, recoverable damages may include past and future medical expenses, lost wages, diminished earning capacity, pain and suffering, and property damage. In wrongful death matters, surviving family members may recover for loss of support, services, and companionship, along with funeral expenses. Which categories apply, and how they are proven, depends on your circumstances and the applicable law.

What if I was partly at fault?

You may still have a claim. Florida applies a comparative fault framework in which your recovery is reduced in proportion to your share of responsibility, subject to statutory limits that have changed in recent years. Insurance adjusters frequently assert that a claimant was more at fault than the evidence supports, because it is an effective way to reduce a payout. That assessment is worth challenging rather than accepting.

What makes your firm different from the ones advertising on television?

Scale and structure. High-volume advertising firms sign a large number of cases and resolve them efficiently, which works reasonably well for straightforward claims. We take substantially fewer cases so that a partner can stay personally involved in each one from intake through resolution. If your matter is straightforward, a volume firm may serve you perfectly well, and we will say so.

What documents should I bring to a consultation?

Bring whatever you have, and do not delay the meeting to gather more. Useful items include any accident or police report, insurance information for all parties, photographs of the scene and your injuries, medical records or discharge paperwork, pay stubs if you have missed work, and any correspondence from insurance companies. If you have none of it, we can obtain most of these ourselves.

Can you help if my family member died as a result of negligence?

Yes. Florida's wrongful death statute allows a personal representative of the estate to bring a claim on behalf of surviving family members. These matters have particular procedural requirements regarding who may recover and in what capacity, and they carry their own deadlines. We handle the procedural work so the family is not managing it during an already difficult period.

Do you handle cases outside Tampa Bay?

We appear in courts throughout Florida and regularly handle matters in surrounding counties. For cases arising in other states we associate with qualified local counsel, which allows the matter to be filed properly while our team continues the substantive work. If a case genuinely belongs with a firm in another jurisdiction, we will tell you and help you find one.

How do I get started?

Call our office at any hour or submit the form on our contact page. A member of the team will speak with you the same business day. The initial consultation is free, carries no obligation, and is confidential whether or not you decide to hire us. If we do not think you need a lawyer, or that another firm is better suited to your case, we will tell you that directly.

FAQ media
Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at (813) 555-0188.
Chat with us on WhatsApp